Physics Says Your Future Already Exists
Premieres
According to the block universe, the past hasn't vanished and the future isn't waiting to be born: every moment exists equally. In 1955, when a friend died, Einstein wrote that the distinction between past, present, and future only has the meaning of an illusion, though a persistent one. In this video we look at how physics arrived at this idea, and why not everyone accepts it.
We'll cover Newton's shared clock, the relativity of simultaneity, Hermann Minkowski's spacetime, the sliced loaf, Penrose's two walkers, the three pictures of time (only the present, the growing block, the whole block), the arrow of time, the two strongest objections, and what all this means for free will.
Which of the three pictures is closest to you: only the present exists, the past and the present exist, or all times are equally there? Tell me in the comments!
Chapters
- A letter from 1955A letter from 1955
- What everyone knows about timeWhat everyone knows about time
- The end of the shared nowThe end of the shared now
- The teacher who put the picture togetherThe teacher who put the picture together
- The sliced loafThe sliced loaf
- If your future is someone else's presentIf your future is someone else's present
- Three pictures of timeThree pictures of time
- So why do we feel it passing?So why do we feel it passing?
- The first objection: the present is localThe first objection: the present is local
- The second objection: the open futureThe second objection: the open future
- And free will?And free will?
- Where do we stand today?Where do we stand today?
- Evening ThoughtEvening Thought
- A question for youA question for you
Sources
A selection of the works and experiments this episode draws on:
- Einstein's letter to the Besso family (1955)
- Minkowski, Space and Time (1908)
- McTaggart, The Unreality of Time (1908)
- Broad, Scientific Thought (1923)
- Eddington (1927)
- Rietdijk (1966)
- Putnam (1967)
- Stein (1968)
- Penrose, The Emperor's New Mind (1989)
- Ellis, the evolving block universe
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Being and Becoming in Modern Physics
- Vonnegut, Slaughterhouse-Five (1969)